Geography is four-dimensional
Articles & Blogs

Geography is four-dimensional

May 4, 2026

<p> Forty years ago, a family moved from India to Canada, and raised their children with “Indian values”. When those children visited <a href="https://sive.rs/meet-chbg">India</a> last year, the locals laughed at their outdated beliefs. What their family had said were <strong>facts</strong> were just a <strong>perspective from 1980</strong>. </p><p> Twenty years ago, I lived in <a href="https://sive.rs/la">Los Angeles</a>. Talking with an old friend that’s still there, I said it’s the nicest place I’ve ever lived, and why. She said, “Oh wow. You haven’t been here in a while. <strong>It’s not like that anymore.</strong>” She said my description was like looking at an old photo from 1999. </p><p> Last year I went to <a href="https://sive.rs/met/at-9">China</a> and loved it. So clean, polite, efficient, and all-around nice. A German friend said I’m crazy because “China is filthy, rude, noisy, and awful - with everyone spitting and pushing.” I asked <strong>when</strong> he was there, and he said <strong>2002</strong>. Ah! But that place is long gone. It’s not like that anymore. </p><p> When someone speaks of a place, you have to ask, “When?” <strong> Geography is four-dimensional. You can’t know a place - only a place as it was at a time. Where is bound to when. </strong> Unless you are in a place right now, you can only speak of it in past-tense. </p><p> I was born in America, but the last year I lived there, George Bush was president. So I’m not from the current place, though it has the same name. </p><p> Like <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backtothe_Future">Doc</a> stepping out of a time machine. “I’m from here, but not <em>this</em> here!” </p><p> I used to describe myself as American, but that’s becoming less true with time. I’m from the America of the 80s, 90s and early 2000s. </p><p> But that place is long gone. It’s not like that anymore. </p>

Read the full piece at https://sive.rs/4d
Jump to
Projectsbrowse
Peoplebrowse
Companiesbrowse
Saved
Editor
Autosaves as you type